Best Miniseries
Fargo
True Detective
Over the Garden Wall
American Horror Story: Freakshow
The category of Best Miniseries was a pretty easy one to decide. I've truly enjoyed Freakshow and Over the Garden Wall was an innovative, artfully done experience, but this was Fargo and True Detective's year. Both were phenomenal, but due to a lame ending, True Detective is barely edged out by Fargo.
Best Lead Male Actor (Miniseries)
Billy Bob Thornton - "Lorne Malvo" - Fargo
Martin Freeman - "Lester Nygaard" - Fargo
Matthew McConaughey - "Rustin Cohle" - True Detective
Woody Harrelson - "Martin Hart" - True Detective
Elijah Wood - "Wirt" - Over the Garden Wall
Once again we find ourselves overwhelmed with True Detective and Fargo. This was by far the hardest category to decide. The first to be marked off were Elijah Wood and Woody Harrelson (bad day for people with "wood" in their names). Harrelson's character didn't have quite as much to work with as McConaughey and Wood was a voice actor who, although great, never reached the heights of his competitors. This left the enigmatic Thornton, the nervously commanding Freeman, and the existential McConaughey. In the end, I thought Freeman put on the best show, being able to be nervous, headstrong, high-strung, and quasi-threatening all at the same time. However, in all honesty all three men deserve an award.
Best Lead Female Actor (Miniseries)
Allison Tolman - "Molly Solverson" - Fargo
Jessica Lange - "Elsa Mars" - American Horror Story: Freakshow
Zoe Saldana - "Rosemary Woodhouse" - Rosemary’s Baby
Essentially no competition. Jessica Lange played another Queen Bitch type character on Freakshow, this time with a German accent. Saldana played a depressed woman who, all things considered, just never even got close to Tolman or Lange.
Best Supporting Male Actor (Miniseries)
Colin Hanks - "Gus Grimly" - Fargo
Keith Carradine - "Lou Solverson" - Fargo
Denis O’Hare - "Stanley" - American Horror Story: Freakshow
Michael Chiklis - "Dell Toledo" - American Horror Story: Freakshow
Oliver Platt - "Stavros Milos" - Fargo
When I first had the idea for the Bennys and started to compile a list of nominees, I thought this category would undoubtedly go to Fargo. However, once Freakshow got going, it became clear that there would be competition. I've always been a fan of Denis O'Hare since he played the mad Vampire King on True Blood. Letting him spread his villainous wings and fly on this season of AHS was a fantastic idea and won him the award.
Best Supporting Female Actor (Miniseries)
Michelle Monaghan - "Maggie Hart" - True Detective
Kathy Bates - "Ethel Darling" - American Horror Story: Freakshow
- Frances Conroy - "Gloria Mott" - American Horror Story: Freakshow
This category would have definitely gone to Frances Conroy had her character stuck around a little longer. Conroy is always fantastic, and so I kept expecting her character to actually do something. Alas, she essentially twiddled her thumbs nervously for eight episodes before having her son shoot her. The same went with Bates. For eight episodes I waited around for her character to get a driving plotline. She got death instead. Thus, Michelle Monaghan, always an interesting side character on True Detective takes the Benny.
Best Writing for a Miniseries
Nic Pizzolatto - True Detective - “The Long Bright Dark”
Nic Pizzolatto - True Detective - “The Secret Fate of All Life”
Patrick McHale - Over the Garden Wall - “Into The Unknown”
Noah Hawley - Fargo - “A Fox, a Rabbit, and a Cabbage”
Noah Hawley - Fargo - “The Crocodile’s Dilemma”
At this point you may think that I'm just a Fargo fanboy. You wouldn't be particularly wrong. However, it is worth pointing out just how fantastic the writing on Fargo's pilot, "The Crocodile's Dilemma" is. In one hour and a half episode, it introduces us to our four leads, several important side characters, and the overall plot. There's major character development in just the first hour, leading to a shocking death and a shocking development. There's foreshadowing, there's symbols, and there's intrigue. Truly amazing writing.
Best Directing for a Miniseries
Colin Bucksey - Fargo - “Buridan’s Ass”
Matt Shakman - Fargo - “Morton’s Fork”
Cary Joji Fukunaga - True Detective - “The Secret Fate of all Life”
Cary Joji Fukunaga - True Detective - “Who Goes There”
Agnieszka Holland - Rosemary’s Baby - “Night 2”
This one was a toughie. Cary Joji Fukunaga was one of the reasons True Detective was so masterful, bringing darkness and an eerie mood to the already dark script. His work on the fourth episode, "Who Goes There" was among his best. The episode ended with an eight minute long tracking shot, showing the escape from an undercover drugbust. It was terrifying, kept the viewer on the edge of their seat, and beautiful in its own way. With that shot alone, it beats out the competition.
Best Reality TV Show
Survivor
Survivor
Survivor
Survivor
Survivor
Was there ever even a thought of competition?
Best New Show
Rick and Morty
The Leftovers
Fargo
True Detective
The Knick
The category of "Best New Show" is a prestigious one this year. Not included on this list were Last Week Tonight, BoJack Horseman, Turn, and The Strain among others. However, to me, just making the top five is an achievement. But, when push comes to shove, there can only be one. And, because there can only be one, it has to be Fargo. Few times before have I been as excited week-to-week as I was when watching Fargo. I can only hope season 2 keeps it up.
Best Opening Sequence
True Blood
Game of Thrones
Hell on Wheels
Boardwalk Empire
The Leftovers
Oh me oh my. HBO just does opening sequences like it's nobody's business. Picking an opening sequence that stands above the rest is quite a feat. My personal favorite will always be Carnivale, but among the shows from 2014, Boardwalk takes it away.